 |
Dr. Andreas Steiner
Photo by David Blumenkrantz |
Incident In Ankoro
1-13-87 Ankoro, Zaire
(Journal entry)
By David Blumenkrantz
Sure enough, we had a magnificent lightning
storm last night. The warm rain came, and
the entire horizon lit up, defining impressive
clouds with intermittent bursts of energy.
. .
We were in living room of Dr. Steiner's
brick Ankoro home. It was Kisimba and I,
along with a local friend of his called
Angelina. Steiner was resting in his bed
after a full day of consultations and operations.
Raphael was in the small kitchen preparing
Steiner's spaghetti dinner. There was a
knock on the door. A harried looking middle-aged
man dressed in ill fitting, dirty clothing
entered nervously. He spoke urgently to
Kisimba in Kiluba. Kisimba rushed in to
get Dr. Steiner--it was a woman at the hospital--
an emergency. That was all I could tell,
but I grabbed my camera gear, preparing
to see the doctor in action at night.
But he didn't go. "The baby is already
dead-- Dr. Kabwe will take care of it."
We jumped in the Land Rover and picked
up Dr. Kabwe, who was waiting in the dark
rain along the road in front of his house.
"Good evening, how are you?" he asked me
in his usual polite manner, oddly incongruous
under the circumstances, I felt. We hurried
down the road to the hospital, accompanied
by lightening and thunder, passing several
people walking down the road, their pace
seemingly unchanged by the weather. Kabwe
was painfully polite-- "You like the jungle?"
He seemed surprised and bit amused that
someone from California could find the bush
conditions so agreeable. I told him so.
In a few minutes we pulled up at the hospital.
I jumped out to open the wooden gate. As
always there were people around the building--
mothers with children, sitting around under
the overhang, calmly talking amongst themselves.
 |
Photo by David Blumenkrantz |
Into the maternity room we barged. Nothing
I'd ever seen, read or heard about could
have prepared me for this situation. On
a stark wooden table a middle-aged women
was lying naked on her back, surrounded
by a small group of attendants and nurses.
She was in intense pain, moaning as they
administered to her. Between her legs hung
the blue-black head of her dead unborn child.
Partially severed arms, white from blood
drainage hung limply alongside. I felt an
ominous weight descend upon me, and was
numbed by the tragic sight, but proceeded
to snap off a few frames. This was to be
one of those situations where you are glad
to have a camera to hide behind . . .
The woman, who had delivered twelve children
in her life, lived in the village of Mukale--
about 25 kilometers of bad road away. An
ignorant "Red Cross Soldier"; a Zairian
outfit about which Dr. Steiner scoffed "know
nothing about medicine, but have nice uniforms,"
had attempted a hackneyed delivery. It was
a stillborn, and in his ill-conceived attempt
to remove the child, had cut away at the
arms and umbilical chord-- severely puncturing
the uterus and causing vast internal bleeding.
 |
Zairean Red Cross
Photo by David Blumenkrantz |
Dr. Kabwe seemed a bit lost. He discussed
the situation at length with his staff,
hesitant to take action. Meanwhile, the
woman had been transported the twenty-five
kilometers (I'm not sure how, most likely
on a makeshift stretcher) with the baby
in its present condition. In an adjacent
bed, another women lay staring straight
ahead, with dull, yellow eyes. It was all
too nonchalant for me. Kabwe at one point
turned to me as I was taking photos, and
said in his deadpan English, "Delivery is
not easy. This is one of the problems of
tropical medicine."
The king of the Zairian understatement
at last decided to consult Dr. Steiner.
Outside the maternity room, the husband
of the woman was standing. He too was dressed
in tattered, filthy clothing. Kisimba said
he was foolish for not bringing her to the
hospital. I asked Kisimba to hear the man's
explanation. He said he had been in another
village fishing when he was summoned. He
seemed disturbed; Kisimba told me he was
deranged. He spoke angrily, growing more
agitated as the hospital staff gathered
round to listen. As we left I put my hand
firmly on the man's shoulder. He returned
my gesture with a blank stare.
We rushed back to get Dr. Steiner, and
found him enthusiastically eating his spaghetti
dinner, complete with a good bottle of Spanish
wine he had brought along. He apologized
for having started without me. His calm
was strangely reassuring. He realized that
what I had seen was "horrible, it's horrible."
He explained that he didn't go at first
because Kabwe had to learn to handle these
things, as he is usually the head doctor
in Ankoro. I barely touched my dinner, though
swallowing a few large glasses of the wine.
Steiner prepared to go to the hospital,
explaining in his best Swiss-German accent
that Kabwe should have just reached in,
and "popped zee baby out." He thought Kabwe
was "perhaps frightened."
Such are the normal occurrences of tropical
medicine. People are hesitant to use the
hospitals, particularly because of the distance.
It is ignorance, I was told; and there are
still the natural healers, or medicine men
whom many people in the bush still prefer
to trust. Stillborns are common in these
remote villages, but this case was extreme.
As Steiner went to the hospital, I stayed
at the house, thinking the emergency was
over. Steiner returned shortly, but the
night was far from over. He had indeed "popped
ze baby right out," but the maneuver was
tricky and in doing so had inadvertently
gone through the existing hole in the uterus
while digging out the last of the baby,
and tore some of the bowel cavity intestines.
As a result, severe bleeding ensued. A nurse
came to the door, and the doctor had to
go back, this time to operate. I went along
to record the operation.
 |
Photo by David Blumenkrantz |
At the hospital I immediately donned the
sterilized mask, hat and rubber beach sandals.
Scrub nurses, wearing African dresses under
their smocks prepared the instruments and
table. In the hallway outside the operating
room, two of the attendants pleaded with
me to take their photograph. I was used
to these requests. The novelty of my camera
had secured as many fast friends as it had
driven people away. But at a time like this?
I took one, and others wanted theirs. It
became ridiculous, with the attendants acting
as though they were walking importantly
down the hallway, then they would laugh
hysterically and give me the thumbs up sign
as I snapped the shutter.
They brought the patient in on a stretcher,
and laid her down in the hallway, while
final preparations were hurriedly being
made behind the double doors. More photo
requests. "Kazi kubwa!" (Important
work!) I insisted. They took this as a sign
that I wanted them to pose working. Five
of them crowded around the suffering woman,
pointing at her or feigning medical care.
It was straight out of the Marx Brothers,
except this woman was bleeding to death.
Into this madness came a shirtless Dr. Steiner.
He ordered the staff into action authoritatively.
The patient was put on the table, anesthetized
and attended to intravenously. As the doctor
was helped on with his smock and gloves,
the woman lay there, naked, her insides
bleeding profusely, her bloated stomach
glistening. From her half-parted lips came
soft, resigned moaning.
At 9:30pm the stomach was cut open, a "midline
incision," and the operation began. The
generator, which normally brought electricity
to the otherwise powerless village hospital
from sundown till 10 each weekday would
stay on late this night. Steiner worked
swiftly, deftly, almost frantically. He
accepted no hesitations or mistakes from
his staff, as he pulled out the uterus,
the remains of the child, and finally about
two feet of small bowel intestines. It was
a horrific site. ("It is horrible, just
horrible," Steiner had reminded me as we
entered the hospital. "Just horrible.")
The patient's eyes were closing, rolling
up. Blood was filling the drainage bottle
beside the operating table, which was surrounded
by the two doctors and a half-dozen sets
of dirty, sandaled feet and the semi-sure
hands of a homegrown staff of trainees.
For me, it was a photographer's field day--
adrenaline pumping as it never had before.
I photographedrelentlessly. It was too grim
for pauses or contemplation. I used all
my lenses, and shot from every angle. Steiner
once had to warn me not to lean on the patient
for risk of infection.
 |
Photo by David Blumenkrantz |
Finally Steiner announced that he had stopped
the bleeding. Still the pace was frantic,
and the accomplished Swiss surgeon became
increasingly impatient with fundamental
mistakes. Brow furrowed permanently, he
implored Kabwe in French, "Sil vous
plait, le doctuerrrrr," drawing out
the last syllable for emphasis. Indeed,
Kabwe was comparatively a trainee alongside
Steiner, a fact not lost on either of them.
This woman would surely have died had Steiner
not been in Ankoro that night.
The operation lasted more than 90 minutes.
Near the end, Steiner announced "It was
a run for life for a while there." He worked
swiftly to close up the stomach. The atmosphere
lightened up a bit. The staff all laughed
when Steiner berated an assistant for cutting
both sutures instead of just one, forcing
him to start anew. A giddiness returned
to the camera hams, who were standing on
footstools behind the doctor, monitoring
an I.V.. They started signaling again for
me to take more photos. I was astonished
at the indifference, the seemingly complete
lack of concern for the significance of
this life-saving operation. (When I questioned
Steiner about this the next morning, he
shrugged it off, explaining, "they do the
job they have to do, but very few get personally
involved with the patient.")
I could understand the average Zairian
villager becoming accustomed to suffering
and death, but I expected medical personnel
to display at least a semblance of a humanitarian,
altruistic motivation. A solid argument
could probably be made to trace the blame
for this phenomenon back to the hollow leadership
of the Zairian government, which has done
virtually nothing, (save for a few sweeping
statements) to promote a sense of responsibility
to millions of people needing just that.
In fairness, it must also be pointed out
that the few attendants who had raised my
ire are not representative of all medical
personnel, and certainly not of the others
present at this operation, who worked serious
professionalism.
When the last stitch was in, Dr. Steiner
sat down in a small storeroom to fill out
the report. I looked back in on the patient.
The operating room was a disaster. The floor
was covered with bloody cloths, cotton,
wrappers and hoses. There were dozens of
dirty tools. The patient lay alone under
the bright
operating lights, naked but for the bandage
on her stomach, which convulsed irregularly--
a sign of life.
Such a frantic effort, to safe the life
of an ignorant villager. This was my introduction
to tropical medicine; this was the third
world. Survival or a horrible, preventable
death, dealt out by the hand of fate. Patchwork
medicine, and operations that the people's
own government does not provide. I thought
of the American public, and refused to accept
the notion that they only care if confronted
with photographs of starving children with
doe-like eyes. And I wondered about the
spirituality of it all, this conflict that
seems to be ever-present, the conflict between
Christian morality and African tradition.
Steiner himself had been beleaguered in
the past by local Methodists for his "unexemplary"
lifestyle. What was it that Steiner had
said to me that first evening in Ankoro,
sipping cold beer as approaching darkness
engulfed us?
"I consider myself a Christian, but not
a fanatic. What we are doing here you could
probably call Christian. If a man drinks,
or loves a woman, this is not so bad; it's
what he does overall that counts." Whatever
has drawn Steiner to this remote, self-contained
existence, he has come to grips with himself
as a self-motivated individual, blending
his better instincts with his more selfish
ones. Another of his remarks comes to mind.
"When I am about to operate on a dying person,
they do not ask me, 'how many women are
you sleeping with?'"
 |
THE AFTERMATH
I was overcome with emotion as I finished
that last entry. I went to my room and closed
the door, and for the first time since I
arrived in Africa, I wept. I felt sadness,
shame, and confusion at the sudden feeling
of powerlessness one experiences when confronted
with such a realization; that underneath
the surface of a romantic notion, reality
is waiting in the form of darkness, pain,
death and sorrow. I think of how the next
time I walk down these dirt roads, the children
will smile and wave, and the adults will
acknowledge me as politely as ever. Do they
ever wonder if I've reached this point in
my awareness of their plight, or am I merely
a symbol of all mzungu's past and present
that have come here seeking business or
pleasure?
And where is the justice? Dr. Kabwe, as
the medical authority of the Ankoro Health
Zone, will arrest and imprison the ignorant
Red Cross Soldier. As I look out my window
now into the sun-bleached afternoon, a lone
boy walks down a humid path. Is the Red
Cross soldier really any guiltier than this
boy? How about the medical assistants who
bugged me for photographs? Not even Dr.
Kabwe was prepared to handle yesterday's
catastrophe. The only guilt I can sense
right now is for humanity. For the Mobutu
regime, certainly-but also for the non-humanitarian
actions of global neighbors who continue
on their paths toward enlightenment through
the pursuit of wealth, while allowing situations
like this to further deteriorate.
I'm sure that I'll feel like myself again
soon, and will be able to laugh with Kisimba
and the others as we attempt to transcend
our cultural barriers. The difference is
that now I know what Dr. Andreas Steiner
has known for a long time, probably since
he took over the stewardship of the Albert
Schweitzer Hospital in Gabon. Every family
I see, crouched on their crude porches or
in front of small fires in some simple village,
demands the same care as the woman resting
now in the Ankoro Hospital. If and when
she returns to her village, it will be without
a uterus or ovaries. Worse for the wear,
she will live out her life with the same
spirits lifting her as before.
Link to Zaire photo gallery (b&w)
Link to Zaire photo gallery (color)
|